Review: Gentlemen Prefer Nerds by Joan Kilby

March 7, 2012 Review 3 ★★★

Review: Gentlemen Prefer Nerds by Joan KilbyRelease Date: March 12, 2012
Title: Gentlemen Prefer Nerds
Author: Joan Kilby
Pages: 257
Publisher: Carina Press
Source: NetGalley
From the Publisher: Self-professed nerd Maddie Maloney is an expert on jewels. Jewel thieves are another matter entirely! So when a mysterious Englishman warns her that a thief known as The Chameleon is after the rare pink diamond on display in her aunt's shop, she tells herself it's just a joke. Even if she can't get Mr. Tall, Dark and Handsome out of her mind...

But Fabian Montgomery doesn't give up easily. He's everywhere she goes, convinced the thief will strike. And when the diamonddoes go missing-and Maddie is suspected of stealing it-he whisks her away from the police and together they pursue The Chameleon.

Fabian plunges her into a glamorous world far from her humble workshop and transforms geeky Maddie into a sophisticated siren capable of espionage. Her mission: to seduce The Chameleon and steal back the diamond.

But Fabian isn't telling her everything-like who he works for, and why he's so interested in The Chameleon...
3 Stars

I gotta be honest: I am a closet fan of romance novels. I started reading them way back in middle school (the torrid ones with the heaving bosoms on the covers), and while I don’t often read them now, I can certainly appreciate a good one. I’m a hopeless romantic as a direct result of my younger self’s obsession with them!

Gentlemen Prefer Nerds is my first non-YA review on the blog, and as such – I’m a little disappointed that I could only give it a 3. But the story just didn’t live up to my expectations. It tried a little too hard to be everything to everybody.

It was cute. It was fun. And I certainly enjoyed reading it. But…

Oh yes, there’s a but.

Maddie was too nerdy and then miraculously turned into the sex kitten she needed to be when necessary? Okay, so she was still a little clumsy – but it was just a little too neat and tidy for my tastes.

And making Fabian a faux 007 just took the cliches right over the top.

And to further add to the cliches was the writing itself.

He wasn’t given to lurid descriptors but one word popped into his mind – she was luscious – with all of the life-giving, taste-tempting, juice sweetness of a perfectly ripe mango.

I actually burst out laughing when I read that. Then I read it again. Then I bookmarked it on my Nook. Then I laughed again.

And really, these things aren’t bad. The book was good! I enjoyed it! But they do prevent it from being great. And it is possible to write some really great romance (see: Diana Gabaldon).

Bottom line: if you want to read a light and fluffy book about a nerd and a Bond-esque Englishman… this is the one to read.

3 Responses to “Review: Gentlemen Prefer Nerds by Joan Kilby”

  1. Amanda @ On a Book Bender

    haha. You just have to laugh at the over the top cliches. Sometimes I think these kinds of books aren’t meant to be great. They’re an escape. They’re good and they serve a purpose. Everyone walks away happy. Yay!

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge